I agree with pretty much everyone on here. In Twilight, Edward is beautiful just as he is described in the book. When New Moon came out, I was seriously disappointed. He now looks much older than 17, his eyebrows are untamed and his hair isn’t as cool. And wow, those contacts and super white makeup just make him looks unrealistic. What happened to the Twilight makeup artist and costume designer??? There must be some way we can get this message to the Breaking Dawn producers. Surely they can return Eward to his original look for the last 2 movies???
Victoria= New Moon
Esme=New Moon
Laurent=New Moon
Bella= New Moon
Edward=100% TWILIGHT they killed it in New Moon
Jacob=So much better in New Moon its ridiculous
Alice= Both
Rosalie= Twlilight
Jasper= Twilight
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle= Definitely Twilight he’s not supposed to look old just because he adopted them in a sense doesnt mean he’s really old when he turned into a vampire he’s just the head of the family/clan with more experience than the rest so i dont see why they made him look older and in a way more chubby in New Moon.
Victoria= New Moon
Esme=New Moon
Laurent=New Moon
Bella= New Moon
Edward=Twilight
Jacob=Definitly in New Moon (So Sexy!!!!)
Alice= Both
Rosalie= Both
Jasper= New Moon
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle= New Moon
VICTORIA=NEW MOON
ESME=NEW MOON
LAURENT=NEW MOON
BELLA=NEW MOON
EDWARD=NEW MOON
JACOB=NEW MOON(HE FINALLY GOT TO TAKE THE WIG OFF)
ROSALIE=NEW MOON AND TWILIGHT
EMMETT=NEW MOON
CARLISLE=NEW MOON
ALICE=SHE LOOKS PRETTY IN BOTH
JASPER=LOKS WAY BETTER IN NEW MOON
Victoria= New Moon
Esma= New Moon
Laurent= New Moon
Bella= Twilight
Jacob= New Moon (HECK YES!)
Rosalie= Both of them look fine. She IS the beautiful one. lol.
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle- Both of them are alright.
Jasper= New Moon (He looks more stable )
Alice= Twilight is okay, but New Moon a little bit better
Edward= Twilight (it shows he is fierce and pale)
I think the make up in twilight was waaaay better…it gave it that vampire feeling cause of there pailness…n I didn’t like how its different 4RM the book…n what’s up wit Bella wearing the same clothes on the part where it says..Sep.Oct.Nov.Dec…where she’s sitting in her room..I thought it was wack..
“n what’s up wit Bella wearing the same clothes on the part where it says..Sep.Oct.Nov.Dec…where she’s sitting in her room..I thought it was wack.”…although i also noticed this in the movie, I allowed for a little flexibility in my judgement-after all, I have also been so depressed that all I have done is sit in my room and stare out the window (and costume changes, or showers for that mattter, were not an essential part of my daily function during that time..
I think the makeup in Twilight is so much better than New Moon. The vampires can’t pass as human in New Moon. It is just way too exagerated in New Moon.
edward is not as attractive in new moon and eclipse. he’s supposed to be 17 but they’ve got him looking like he’s in his mid 20’s. his face color was weird in italy. his eyebrows are too big and bushy and his hair is too grown out. it makes his head look very big. it’s not as cool as it was in twilight. it’s very sad. i still follow the story and will watch the movies but i don’t swoon for edward the same anymore.
The makeup in New Moon was far too harsh for my liking. Twlight’s makeup especially Edward’s was far more subtle and more believable. New Moon’s makeup and now Ecilpse’s looks yet again to have gone far too white. Whilst I agree that the New Moon’s whole look was more polished for me Edward especially was to white.
Twilight makeup soooooooo much better than new moon. New moon was freaky , overdone . the new contacts and wigs were absolutely terrible – made it so diffiult to believe that the vampires were meant to a) pass off as humans and b) be so incredibly attractive – they just look like freaks. Both bella and edward looked far better in twilight . In fact, having just watched both again on DVD – I have come full circle and think twilight is a superior movie and much better adaptation of the book.
Everyone sees and likes something different – but I just want to say Victoria is so stunning and able to pull off either look in film or the real world!
Also, I much prefered both Bella and Edward in Twilight. I understand that the director was adjusting their looks according to the changes in their characters but there was no need. They were so appropriate in the first film and the idea of changing something that works bothers me!
Jacob went from boy to man – so he had to change and Alice also went thru a maturing process so I understand the necessary changes in her look also.
Rosalie and Jasper were let down by their terrible wigs – which is so unfortunate as they are two attractive people who were not done justice!
Everyone else looked much the same to me – but overall more polished yet manacing enough in Twilight as opposed to New Moon!!
August 29th, 2010 at 7:54 am
ALL OF THEM NEW MOON EXCEPT FOR BELLA SHE ALWAYS LOOKED UGLY N ALWAYS WILL!!
August 23rd, 2010 at 4:45 am
ALL OF THEM LOOK GOOD IN BOTH EXCEPT JAKE HE LOOKS MUCH BETTER IN NEW MOON WITHOUT HIS UGLY WIG
July 9th, 2010 at 8:06 am
I agree with pretty much everyone on here. In Twilight, Edward is beautiful just as he is described in the book. When New Moon came out, I was seriously disappointed. He now looks much older than 17, his eyebrows are untamed and his hair isn’t as cool. And wow, those contacts and super white makeup just make him looks unrealistic. What happened to the Twilight makeup artist and costume designer??? There must be some way we can get this message to the Breaking Dawn producers. Surely they can return Eward to his original look for the last 2 movies???
July 8th, 2010 at 9:42 pm
Victoria= New Moon
Esme=New Moon
Laurent=New Moon
Bella= New Moon
Edward=100% TWILIGHT they killed it in New Moon
Jacob=So much better in New Moon its ridiculous
Alice= Both
Rosalie= Twlilight
Jasper= Twilight
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle= Definitely Twilight he’s not supposed to look old just because he adopted them in a sense doesnt mean he’s really old when he turned into a vampire he’s just the head of the family/clan with more experience than the rest so i dont see why they made him look older and in a way more chubby in New Moon.
June 22nd, 2010 at 7:16 pm
Victoria= New Moon
Esme=New Moon
Laurent=New Moon
Bella= New Moon
Edward=Twilight
Jacob=Definitly in New Moon (So Sexy!!!!)
Alice= Both
Rosalie= Both
Jasper= New Moon
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle= New Moon
June 21st, 2010 at 11:48 am
VICTORIA=NEW MOON
ESME=NEW MOON
LAURENT=NEW MOON
BELLA=NEW MOON
EDWARD=NEW MOON
JACOB=NEW MOON(HE FINALLY GOT TO TAKE THE WIG OFF)
ROSALIE=NEW MOON AND TWILIGHT
EMMETT=NEW MOON
CARLISLE=NEW MOON
ALICE=SHE LOOKS PRETTY IN BOTH
JASPER=LOKS WAY BETTER IN NEW MOON
June 9th, 2010 at 10:12 pm
Victoria= New Moon
)
Esma= New Moon
Laurent= New Moon
Bella= Twilight
Jacob= New Moon (HECK YES!)
Rosalie= Both of them look fine. She IS the beautiful one. lol.
Emmett= New Moon
Carlisle- Both of them are alright.
Jasper= New Moon (He looks more stable
Alice= Twilight is okay, but New Moon a little bit better
Edward= Twilight (it shows he is fierce and pale)
May 17th, 2010 at 4:44 pm
I think the make up in twilight was waaaay better…it gave it that vampire feeling cause of there pailness…n I didn’t like how its different 4RM the book…n what’s up wit Bella wearing the same clothes on the part where it says..Sep.Oct.Nov.Dec…where she’s sitting in her room..I thought it was wack..
July 21st, 2010 at 12:02 pm
“n what’s up wit Bella wearing the same clothes on the part where it says..Sep.Oct.Nov.Dec…where she’s sitting in her room..I thought it was wack.”…although i also noticed this in the movie, I allowed for a little flexibility in my judgement-after all, I have also been so depressed that all I have done is sit in my room and stare out the window (and costume changes, or showers for that mattter, were not an essential part of my daily function during that time..
May 16th, 2010 at 8:58 pm
I think the makeup in Twilight is so much better than New Moon. The vampires can’t pass as human in New Moon. It is just way too exagerated in New Moon.
May 14th, 2010 at 1:08 am
edward is not as attractive in new moon and eclipse. he’s supposed to be 17 but they’ve got him looking like he’s in his mid 20’s. his face color was weird in italy. his eyebrows are too big and bushy and his hair is too grown out. it makes his head look very big. it’s not as cool as it was in twilight. it’s very sad. i still follow the story and will watch the movies but i don’t swoon for edward the same anymore.
May 2nd, 2010 at 10:32 am
The makeup in New Moon was far too harsh for my liking. Twlight’s makeup especially Edward’s was far more subtle and more believable. New Moon’s makeup and now Ecilpse’s looks yet again to have gone far too white. Whilst I agree that the New Moon’s whole look was more polished for me Edward especially was to white.
April 25th, 2010 at 6:15 am
Twilight makeup soooooooo much better than new moon. New moon was freaky , overdone . the new contacts and wigs were absolutely terrible – made it so diffiult to believe that the vampires were meant to a) pass off as humans and b) be so incredibly attractive – they just look like freaks. Both bella and edward looked far better in twilight . In fact, having just watched both again on DVD – I have come full circle and think twilight is a superior movie and much better adaptation of the book.
April 22nd, 2010 at 10:01 am
Everyone sees and likes something different – but I just want to say Victoria is so stunning and able to pull off either look in film or the real world!
Also, I much prefered both Bella and Edward in Twilight. I understand that the director was adjusting their looks according to the changes in their characters but there was no need. They were so appropriate in the first film and the idea of changing something that works bothers me!
Jacob went from boy to man – so he had to change and Alice also went thru a maturing process so I understand the necessary changes in her look also.
Rosalie and Jasper were let down by their terrible wigs – which is so unfortunate as they are two attractive people who were not done justice!
Everyone else looked much the same to me – but overall more polished yet manacing enough in Twilight as opposed to New Moon!!