Selena Gomez “A Year Without Rain” vs Luce’s “Buy A Dog”

May 1, 2012

yearrain

Selena Gomez & The Scene could in trouble for their single “A Year Without Rain.”

According to Gossip Cop, the 19-year-old’s song features a chorus that’s “virtually identical” to the band Luce’s 2005 track “Buy A Dog.”

Selena Gomez & the Scene are being sued for a $1 million.

Take a listen to both tracks below. What do you think?

67Post a Comment

Subscribe

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

67 Responses to “Selena Gomez “A Year Without Rain” vs Luce’s “Buy A Dog””

  1. jamie Says:

    exactly alike………

    Reply

  2. munuali Says:

    THE SONGS DON’T SOUND NTHING ALIKE.. A year Without Rain sounds better.

    SELENA GOMEZ. YOU ARE MY HERO.. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH AND I LOVE ALL UR SONGS..<3<3<3

    AND I HOPE YOU GET OUT OF THE LAWSUIT SOON. <3<3<3

    Reply

  3. munuali Says:

    THEY SONGS DON’T SOUND NTHING ALIKE.. SELENA GOMEZ SONG SOUND BETTER.. AND PEOPLE CAN LISTEN TO A Year Without Rain.. HER SONG IS MORE CLEAR DEN THEIR :=( AM REALLY SORRY IF YOU GUYS SAID SELENA COPY THE SONG..

    Reply

  4. Cami Says:

    it does sound a lot a like, but oh well if the band was famous because i don’t know them so i don’t know. Sorry guys you guys aren’t that popular probably that’s why Selena “COPY” you guys!

    Reply

  5. Maitha Says:

    Not the same at all !

    Reply

  6. Colleen Says:

    Buy a dog is NOTHING like selena’s song!

    Reply

  7. Tricia Says:

    holy, not the same whatsoever. this is ridiculous! LOL. the just are not well known they need money from a super famous gal,

    Reply

  8. Janice Says:

    yeah yeah yeah i kile selena alot but the cartoon beat her.really runny and actually entertaining xxx

    Reply

  9. Laura Says:

    Woooooooww. It’s possible, maybe the Scene or the writers of this song had Luce’s song on the brain. good luck getting out of that one. I’ve never hear two songs so similar!

    Reply

  10. Allison Says:

    I like Selena’s song, but it is copyright. Exactly the same. Whether you can ‘hear’ it or not. Luce wins.

    Reply

  11. Andy Says:

    Tbh selena’s version is alot better, but when you just take that away for the song, and get rid of the song, They do sound pretty much identical, just in a different key.

    But tbh i dnt think they copied it, its just a coincidence.

    Reply

  12. Jamie Says:

    Really ? It doesn’t even sound familiar to me ? Is there something wrong with my ear?

    Reply

  13. Ashley Snowden Says:

    That’s so dumb, Selenas song is so much better and original because it’s her and the band,the other band has a similar beat but is dumb because they use a whole bunch of different videos to make they’re dumb vide.I bet they’re only suing because they’re broke chumps that didn’t succeed with they’re career. Buy a dog really? With out rain is a love song and makes sence. And they’re tons of songs out there with a similar beat.So they shouldn’t pay a dime to those bums, if anything they put great use to the beat.

    Reply

  14. mel Says:

    I should just write lyrics to this music too, then I can be just like Selena.

    Reply

  15. Delanie Says:

    Yeah, it’s similar, but there are so many songs in the world. somethings are just going to be the same, coincidently of course. I think that If Selena took the lyrics that would be something to sue for.

    Reply

    • Luqman Says:

      Yeah she did not copy the lyrics…then i can only guess this luce band sued her just ot get money from her…anyway i cant detect any similarity

      Reply

  16. YASMIN LAMOTHE Says:

    OK. I CAN SEE A LITTLE SIMILARITY BUT NOT WITH THE LYRICS. ITS WITH THE TUNE OF THE CHORUS: THEY DO SOUND ALMOST THE SAME. TRY FITTING THE WORDS OF A YEAR WITHOUT RAIN INTO IT. BUT IVE NEVER EVER HEARD OF THESE GUYS AND I AGREE THAT THEY JUST WANT PUBLICITY.

    Reply

    • Selena Fan Says:

      I agree! I don’t think Selena should pay the money! That band.. “Luce” just want publicity!

      Reply

      • Luqman Says:

        agreed….they band isnt popular anymore and they just want her to pay them money…thts so sickk…i hope selena gets out of the lawsuit soon!

        Reply

  17. Rebecca Says:

    In some parts it is similar, but they aren’t the same

    Reply

  18. marco Says:

    Selenas songs sounds nothing like luces.. selena i got your back.. dont worry

    Reply

  19. Sarah Says:

    I don’t see the similarities………..Just Saying. I haven’t even heard of Luce EVER. I hope the lawsuit is taken off and everything is ok. Money grabbers suck! And plus how long has the song been out?

    Reply

    • Kate Says:

      The fact that you have never heard of Luce is irrelevant. The fact is that the chorus is way too similar, and what’s right is right. It was copied by other songwriters and coincidentally became a hit by her. Luce deserves payback.

      Reply

  20. Rachel Says:

    What?????? They sound nothing alike! I can’t believe Luce had to put a lawsuit on this!!!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Connect with Facebook